Was Paul Bunyan Real?

  • Paul Bunyan illustration
Paul Bunyan illustration
Credit: CSA-Printstock/ iStock
Author Timothy Ott

November 14, 2024

Love it?

Even in this age of internet-inspired distractions, Paul Bunyan remains a well-known figure in the pantheon of American icons. It’s easy to see why when considering his portfolio. A hardworking lumberjack, Bunyan cleared entire forests with a single stroke of his ax; created natural formations such as the Grand Canyon with his sheer size and strength; and was even kind to animals, as illustrated by his longtime companionship with Babe the Blue Ox. No fewer than six towns lay claim to being his birthplace, while others boast a variety of Bunyan statues, restaurants, and events.

Of course, part of the attraction to this legendary figure stems from the exaggerations inherent to the tall-tale tradition. We know there wasn’t really a human so massive he needed to be carried by five storks as a baby and created entire lakes when his footsteps filled with water. On the other hand, it’s often pointed out that truth is stranger than fiction, so perhaps there was a real-life lumberjack so unusually strong and brave that he inspired the character who grew to such outlandish proportions in the stories that followed. Peering back through the legend’s many branches, here’s a look at where and when this larger-than-life woodsman first marked his presence.

Credit: CSA-Printstock/ DigitalVision Vectors via Getty Images

The Possible Real-Life Inspiration for Bunyan

One candidate for the real-life Bunyan was a French Canadian logger by the name of Fabian “Saginaw Joe” Fournier. A large man who supposedly sported two full sets of adult teeth, Fournier was known for his shows of strength and hard-drinking ways, until he was killed in the rough-and-tumble logging town of Bay City, Michigan, in 1875.

The other main hypothesized model for the tall-tale icon was a French Canadian lumberman named Bon Jean, an alleged participant in Lower Canada’s Papineau Rebellion of 1837. Bon Jean’s formidable reputation spread across the border by way of his countrymen who sought work in the Great Lakes region, and, the theory goes, his Québécois moniker was eventually Americanized to “Bunyan.”

However, according to Michael Edmonds, author of Out of the Northwoods: The Many Lives of Paul Bunyan, there are problems with both of these origin stories. The source of the Fournier theory was a logger-turned-writer named James MacGillivray, who published some of the earliest newspaper stories about Bunyan in the early 20th century. But his own source proved to be dubious. Decades later, MacGillivray wrote in a letter how he’d learned of the Fournier connection from a timber cruiser (land appraiser) named Jimmy Conn. However, that contradicted an earlier account of MacGillivray’s in which he claimed to have heard of Fournier back in 1887, a time when Conn was just a teenager and too young to hold such an advanced position.

Edmonds traces the Papineau Rebellion theory, meanwhile, to author James Stevens, who relayed the anecdotes of a French Canadian old-timer for his popular 1925 book about Bunyan. Over the years, the identity of this participant in the uprising was fused with that of a French Canadian folk character named Bon Jean. However, researchers who combed the archives of information related to the rebellion found no mention of a Bunyan or anyone with a similar name.

It’s quite possible that a logger with bulging muscles and nerves of steel made his way into the first Bunyan tales by hauling a massive white pine trunk or overpowering a vicious beast of the north woods. However, the identity of such an individual — or individuals — was unknown when researchers first began digging for him more than a century ago, and it remains unknown today with the original sources long gone.

You may also like

These Retro Toys Are the Perfect Unique Gifts for All Ages

  • Boy with Lincoln Logs
Boy with Lincoln Logs
Credit: H. Armstrong Roberts/ClassicStock/ Archive Photos via Getty Images
Author Kristina Wright

November 13, 2024

Love it?

Ready to take a trip down memory lane? Before tablets, touchscreens, and Wi-Fi, toys were all about tactile fun, imagination, and the joy of hands-on play. Today, retro toys carry a special charm, reminding us of simpler times when even a bouncy spring or simple building blocks could offer hours of entertainment. In a world where tech toys are constantly evolving, these classics have stayed true to their roots — some have barely changed from their original designs, while others have adapted for new audiences in surprising ways.

Whether you’re looking to reconnect with your childhood favorites or introduce a new generation to the magic of these timeless playthings, these retro toys will bring a touch of nostalgia.

Credit: Ken Howard/ Alamy Stock Photo 

Rock ’Em Sock ’Em Robots (1965)

With the tagline “Knock his block off!” and a comic book-worthy illustration on the box, Rock ’Em Sock ’Em Robots quickly captivated audiences when they were introduced in 1965 by toy designer Marvin Glass. This two-person game featuring boxing robots Red Rocker and Blue Bomber inspired many a playful boxing match in the decades that followed, and is still capturing imaginations today. A live-action movie starring Vin Diesel is rumored to be in the works, but until these toy robots hit the big screen, you can find them at Walmart for $21.92.

You may also like

We Cooked the World’s Oldest Written Recipes

  • Two bowls of food
Two bowls of food
Credit: Original photography by Bennett Kleinman
Author Bennett Kleinman

November 7, 2024

Love it?

The ancient Babylonians, who lived in modern-day Iran, Iraq, Turkey, and Syria as far back as the early second millennium BCE, were among the earliest human civilizations. They pioneered such concepts as written language, legal justice, and mathematics, and the culinary arts are no exception: The world’s earliest written recipes survive today in the form of ancient Babylonian tablets dating to around 1730 BCE. The tablets were unearthed in the 1920s, but were initially thought to be medical texts. It wasn’t until the 1980s that researchers finally deduced that the artifacts actually comprised an early cookbook — in fact, it’s considered to be the oldest surviving cookbook in the world. 

I was curious to see how these early recipes tasted — especially compared to contemporary dishes — so I set out to recreate a couple of them and try them myself. One of the three tablets contains a summary of 25 recipes for various stews and broths, while the other two describe those recipes in more detail. But the tablets still lack critical specifics, such as exact ingredient amounts and cooking times. The translation for one recipe, for instance, simply says, “Meat is not used. You prepare water. You add fat…” and so on, which would have been hard to replicate. Luckily, a team at Yale University used the information on the tablets, along with their scholarly knowledge of ancient Babylon, to compile several modern recipes that are considered accurate interpretations of those ancient meals. 

Using their findings, I prepared two of the recipes at home: a lamb and beet stew, and a vegetarian broth whose name has been translated as “unwinding.” (Though it’s unclear why it’s called “unwinding,” experts suggest it could have been a dish people ate to relax.) Despite the ancient nature of these recipes, it wasn’t difficult to compile the ingredients, or at the very least suitable substitutes. 

Lamb and Beet Stew

The primary dish I made was a lamb stew. Lambs were among several animals that were domesticated in ancient Mesopotamia, and were a key component of cuisine in the region. Mesopotamia was also an agricultural hot spot that came to be known as the Fertile Crescent — referring to the area’s rich, fertile soil — so it comes as little surprise that the lamb stew contained plenty of fresh veggies as well. 

Credit: Original photography by Bennett Kleinman
  • Ingredients
  • 1 pound diced lamb leg
  • ½ cup rendered fat (we used cow fat instead of sheep fat)
  • ½ teaspoon salt
  • 1 cup beer
  • ½ cup water
  • 1 small chopped onion
  • 1 cup chopped arugula
  • 1 cup spring onions
  • ½ cup cilantro
  • 1 teaspoon cumin
  • 1 pound diced red beets
  • ½ cup chopped leek
  • 2 cloves garlic
  • Coriander seed, cilantro, and kurrat (we used spring onion) for garnish

For this dish, I had to make a few minor adjustments given the ingredients I had available. The recipe as written called for an Egyptian leek called kurrat, which is known for having a mild onion and garlicky flavor. Given the similar flavor profile, spring onions are a suitable alternative, so I used those instead.

The dish also calls for beer, which was a major component of Babylonian culture. It was difficult, of course, to find a beer that would have been exactly like the ones drunk by the ancient Babylonians, but I looked for an option that was as close as possible. Most of the beer recipes archaeologists have uncovered from ancient Babylon are made with barley. Tate Paulette, the author of In the Land of Ninkasi: A History of Beer in Ancient Mesopotamia, writes that “there’s no evidence for the use of hops” in Babylonian beer, unlike in modern beers. He also notes that early beers often included “date syrup, and additional flavorings,” giving them a sweetness. Brew Your Own magazine, meanwhile, points out that many ancient beers were sour in nature. Taking all this into account, I selected a fruity and sour ale to roughly replicate the taste profile of Babylonian beer.

Credit: Original photography by Bennett Kleinman

The cooking process for this dish was rather simple, and not unlike how you’d prepare any modern stew. The major difference was how heat was applied — while cooks in ancient Babylon would’ve used an open flame, I used an electric stovetop. 

You may also like

6 Photos That Define the 1950s

  • Marilyn Monroe with billowing skirt
Marilyn Monroe with billowing skirt
Credit: photo-fox/ Alamy Stock Photo
Author Tony Dunnell

November 7, 2024

Love it?

The 1950s were a decade of profound change and contrast, both in American society and globally. For the U.S. in particular, it was an era marked by postwar optimism, economic prosperity, and technological advancements. But it was also a decade of social tensions, Cold War fears, and the ever-increasing stirrings of cultural revolution. These complexities were captured in the period’s photography, from celebrity snaps by the burgeoning paparazzi to powerful images of the Civil Rights Movement taken by experienced photojournalists.

Here are six photos that encapsulate the spirit and struggles of the decade, and have become iconic images of the 1950s.

Credit: Bettmann via Getty Images

Einstein Sticking Out His Tongue (1951)

This playful photograph of Albert Einstein sticking out his tongue was taken on the renowned scientist’s 72nd birthday on March 14, 1951. Einstein was seated between Frank Aydelotte, head of the Institute of Advanced Study in Princeton, New Jersey, and his wife at a birthday celebration. The paparazzi were lurking outside, hoping to hear from — or at least take a photo of — the world-famous professor. According to some accounts, Einstein was irritated by the photographers and so he stuck his tongue out at them. Whatever his motives, the resulting photo — captured by United Press International photographer Arthur Sasse — was one of levity. It helped establish Einstein’s public image as the “nutty professor,” humanizing one of the greatest scientific minds of the 20th century. Einstein himself loved the photo and had it put on greetings cards that he sent out to friends. 

You may also like

7 Common Items That Used To Be Extremely Valuable

  • Pineapples awaiting shipment
Pineapples awaiting shipment
Credit: Bettmann via Getty Images
Author Tony Dunnell

November 7, 2024

Love it?

When we take a look back through history, we find that many items we now consider commonplace were once rare, exotic, and incredibly valuable. These precious commodities were often out of reach for the majority of people, reserved for royalty and wealthy citizens.

The journey of these items from scarcity to ubiquity tells a fascinating story of human progress, a tale of technological advancements and shifting global economics. Centuries of exploration, agricultural developments, industrial innovations, and the opening of new trade routes transformed our material world. What was once worth its weight in gold may now be found in every household, often used — or even discarded — without a second thought.

Here are some now-common items that have undergone this remarkable transition, from spices that once financed entire cities to beverages that sparked riots and wars. 

Credit: Sepia Times/ Universal Images Group via Getty Images

Salt and Pepper

Salt and pepper were often known as “white gold” and “black gold,” respectively, by merchants of the ancient world. Salt was once essential not just for flavoring food but also for preserving it, making it crucial for survival and expansion. It was transported along the ancient salt routes to markets across Europe, making some citizens, cities, and regions extremely wealthy. The city of Salzburg in Austria, for example, whose name literally means “Salt Castle,” amassed great wealth by trading salt. Pepper, meanwhile, was once so rare and desirable that it was literally worth its weight in gold and was sometimes used as currency. The desire for salt and pepper, along with other spices, was so high that it helped drive European global exploration in the 15th and 16th centuries. 

You may also like

Why Are Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, Virginia, and Kentucky Called Commonwealths?

  • Map of Virginia
Map of Virginia
Credit: Bennian/ Shutterstock
Author Nicole Villeneuve

November 7, 2024

Love it?

The United States is made up of 50 states, yet four of them — Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, Virginia, and Kentucky — are officially referred to as commonwealths. Their names are technically styled as the Commonwealth of Virginia, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, etc. The term “commonwealth” is frequently associated with Great Britain, and its ongoing alignment with many countries that were formerly part of the British Empire. But in the U.S., which was also once under British rule, the term has a somewhat different meaning. 

A commonwealth is defined as a political entity founded for the good of the people. The word dates back to the mid-15th century and was given weight by political philosophers such as John Locke and Thomas Hobbes throughout the 17th century. The term was also popularized during this period due to the execution of England’s King Charles I in 1649. After the king’s death, the country was declared a republic, and was known as the Commonwealth of England until the monarchy was restored in 1660. 

This concept of a state existing for the benefit of its citizens — not for any one individual, such as a monarch — is the idea behind the use of the word in the United States. Its use dates back to colonial times and the revolutionary ideals of governance and political rhetoric that were paramount to the cause of American independence. 

You may also like

What Did Oranges Used To Look Like? (They Weren’t Always Orange)

  • Still life of oranges, 1863
Still life of oranges, 1863
Credit: Heritage Images/ Hulton Archive via Getty Images
Author Tony Dunnell

November 7, 2024

Love it?

When we think of oranges today, we picture an almost perfectly round fruit with a sweet, citric, juicy interior that is, as the name suggests, orange in color. It’s a common fruit around the world; in the U.S., oranges consistently rank as the third-most-consumed fresh fruit behind bananas and apples — and it ranks No. 1 among juices. 

But oranges weren’t always as popular or as common as they are today — and they didn’t even look the same. The oranges we’re familiar with are the result of thousands of years of cultivation and selective breeding. Here, we peel back the layers of history to discover what oranges used to look like and how they evolved into the fruit we enjoy today.

Credit: Sepia Times/ Universal Images Group via Getty Images

The Origins of Oranges

Oranges, and all other citrus fruits, can trace their roots to the southeast foothills of the Himalayas. According to DNA evidence, the first citrus trees appeared in this region about 8 million years ago; from there, they spread across the Indian subcontinent and then to south-central China. These ancient citrus fruits, however, were nothing like the oranges we know today. They were smaller, often bitter, and came in a variety of shapes and colors, from knobby, yellow fruits akin to the modern citron to large, green, smooth-skinned citruses similar to the modern pomelo.

All the oranges, lemons, limes, and grapefruits we eat today are descendants of just a handful of ancient species, namely citrons, pomelos, and mandarins, all native to South Asia and East Asia. The sweet orange we know today, which accounts for about 70% of global orange production, is a cultivated hybrid of the ancient pomelo — a large, pale green or yellow fruit with a thick rind — and ancient mandarins, which were then only a little larger than olives. That original hybrid, however, would have been quite different from the oranges we have today.  

You may also like

What $20 Could Buy You Through History

  • $20 bill
$20 bill
Credit: enginakyurt11/ iStock
Author Nicole Villeneuve

October 31, 2024

Love it?

Imagine walking into a grocery store with $20 in your pocket. What can you buy? Today, you might be able to grab some pasta and vegetables for the night’s dinner and have leftovers for tomorrow’s lunch, if you’re lucky. The purchasing power of a dollar has changed dramatically from the early days of American history, largely due to the ever-increasing prices of the things we spend money on — that pesky reality we call inflation. Twenty bucks might not put much in your grocery bag now, but in the mid-20th century, it could easily stock your pantry — or even cover a visit to the doctor. Here’s what $20 could comfortably buy you at different times in U.S. history.

Credit: Fotosearch/ Archive Photos via Getty Images

Colonial Era

The colonial American economy primarily used a mix of British currency (pounds, shillings, and pence), Spanish dollars, and various forms of local currency. There was no unified economic system; the value of money and exchange rates varied among colonies, and historians admit it’s a challenge to draw direct comparisons to modern prices. Using various online converters, we can loosely estimate $20 to be equivalent to about 100 shillings at the time. In the 1730s, 20 shillings could buy 50 acres of land in Maryland or about 3 pounds of beef in New England. In 1777, the same amount would outfit a man in a full suit of broadcloth in Rhode Island. 

Of course, while it’s fun to speculate, it’s nearly impossible to determine with any certainty how much $20 was worth in colonial America, as there was no standard national currency until the U.S. won independence at the end of the Revolutionary War.

You may also like

When Did People Start Using Money? 

  • Examining ancient coins
Examining ancient coins
Credit: BINK0NTAN/ Shutterstock
Author Timothy Ott

October 31, 2024

Love it?

It’s been said that money makes the world go round. It’s also been said that money is the root of all evil. Whichever theory you subscribe to, both of these contrasting views highlight the ubiquity of currency in modern society. 

We often take for granted the process of shelling out cash for food at the grocery store, setting aside regular amounts for the mortgage or rent, or spending a few extra bucks on a new shirt or shoes. These are the hallmarks of modern living — but they haven’t always been.

Humans have been around for about 300,000 years, began banding together in settlements some 12,000 years ago, and set the foundations of major civilizations 5,500 years ago. So when did the all-encompassing presence of money enter the equation?

Credit: Shutterstock AI Generator/ Shutterstock

Bartering and Neolithic Cattle

Historians agree that before there was money, there was bartering — the exchange of one form of goods or services for another in a way that satisfied both parties. This process dates back thousands of years, to at least the Upper Paleolithic period (roughly 50,000 to 10,000 years ago). But experts differ as to the next steps in the economic timeline, depending on their specialty. Some economists have argued, based on the writings of Adam Smith in The Wealth of Nations, that money developed from the bartering system. However, scholars in the fields of anthropology and archaeology are more likely to contend that money was created by governments as a means of exerting control. Part of the uncertainty, of course, comes from the difficulty of tracing the development of a system across different parts of the world with a lack of definitive recorded evidence. 

However it was introduced, ancient money generally fulfilled a few major guidelines: It served as a unit of exchange, represented a measure of value, enabled the payment of debts, and could be accumulated as a wealth reserve. Prior to the existence of metallic coins and (far later) paper cash, this meant the use of a wide array of items that fulfilled some combination of practical and ornamental function.

The oldest form of money may well be the use of cattle dating back to the Neolithic era — while far less portable than modern forms of money, it fit the other requirements of providing a standard measure of value and being easily counted. Other nonmetallic forms of currency from various cultures through the centuries include amber, beads, cocoa beans, ivory, leather, quartz, rice, salt, and whale teeth.

You may also like

The Evolution of Hemlines Through History

  • Pleated skirts circa 1966
Pleated skirts circa 1966
Credit: Roger Viollet Collection via Getty Images
Author Nicole Villeneuve

October 30, 2024

Love it?

Worn by both men and women in early civilizations such as Egypt and Rome, skirts and dresses gradually transformed into quintessential symbols of femininity in the Western world. For centuries, these garments reached the floor as a mark of modesty, but practicality and changing tastes occasionally nudged hemlines higher, such as with the “walking dress” and its ankle-skimming hem, which emerged by the mid-1800s. By the late 19th century, it wasn’t unheard of to see a skirt hit midcalf, a look that forecasted the more dramatic shifts that started in the early 1900s. 

While we tend to think of the evolution of hemlines as a simple upward trajectory, getting shorter as society evolved and fashion became more daring, their history is much more nuanced. Hemlines have risen and fallen several times in the last 100 years. And though the popular “hemline index” theory suggests that skirt lengths rise in times of economic prosperity and fall during downturns, that’s an oversimplification of the story. Far from a one-way trend, hemlines have been a dynamic reflection of fashion, function, and symbolism through the years. Here are a few of the most significant changes in the 20th century.

Credit: Kirn Vintage Stock/ Corbis Historical via Getty Images

1920s: The Flapper Era

The 1920s marked the first major departure from traditional floor-length skirts. Following World War I, the Roaring ’20s brought economic stability to the U.S. — and a newfound sense of empowerment and liberation for women, who had won the right to vote in 1920. Women enjoyed vibrant social lives even in the depths of Prohibition, frequenting speakeasies and private clubs and dancing the night away. It was a time when the restrictive clothing of the past just would not do; hemlines shot up, at first to just below the knee, and by the mid-1920s, even creeping above. The new dress style also did away with the tightly corseted fashions of earlier decades, ushering in a less-structured “Garçonne” look (an androgynous or “tomboy” style) that was free of curves and had dropped waists, loose fits, and a straighter silhouette.

You may also like